Videomaker – Learn video production and editing, camera reviews › Forums › Cameras and Camcorders › Professional Camcorders › Camera for Martial Arts video
December 25, 2012 at 11:32 AM #52561
I am about to start my video business, focusing on producing Martial Arts instructional DVDs, so I will need to buy a camcorder – I have no experience with pro/ semi-pro camcorders, so its a little hard for me to pick the right one, and my budget for it – about $2000 is too much to spend on something that wont work as I expect it to. Unfortunately I live on the end of the world (Yukon) and dont have access to video shop where I could try out different cameras.
The one thing that I really didnt like when working with non-professional cameras was automatic focus – with all the movements of martial arts videos is definatelly essential to have manual focus (and I would like to have zoom and iris manual too, just to have more control over the video)
As for now I chose JVC GY-HM150U, but please let me know of other alternatives.
Thank you 🙂
December 26, 2012 at 10:09 AM #205360
I use the GY-HM100U for the same thing and love it.
I think the GY-HM150U is a great choice
December 26, 2012 at 10:12 AM #205361
December 27, 2012 at 1:37 PM #205385CharlesParticipant
Whatever camera you get make sure it has CCD sensors instead of CMOS. With a CMOS sensor you would wind up with some pretty bad footage with the fast motion.
December 30, 2012 at 11:30 AM #205430
December 30, 2012 at 4:20 PM #205436
January 2, 2013 at 12:22 PM #205482laoshi09Participant
I've been filming amateur MMA events in my area for about three years now. I might get some flack for my two cents but this is what works for me. My cameras are Sony FX7s and yes they use tape which when loading into your computer is a long drawn out affair. But the Sonys can also take photos without stopping the video. This is extremely important to the promoter especially when I get the money shot(s). I literally take hundreds of photos per camera during a 10 fight event.
I believe that almost any prosumer or professional camera would work as long as they have 3 CCDs or CMOS. I do not manually focus because there is just not enough time. I need to keep it simple. Actually it is the cameraperson not the camera (within reason) that makes the video in a cage fight. The action is fast and brutal. The cameraperson MUST focus and follow the action.
You can't get distracted and you have to follow with the LCD not direct or with the eyepeice. You can't just zoom willy-nilly as the action is moving around too fast. You have to wait until the ground & pound to zoom for the close-ups. Tripods just don't make sense here. My camera people use stands to get above the cage for the action, but I personally use a Hi-Pod system which is extremely flexible. Now, these events are not for everyone and my technique may not work for any of you, but that's my two cents and it is something to think about. Good luck!
Also, check out my website for some fight examples: http://www.WDJProductions.net
January 2, 2013 at 12:40 PM #205484AnonymousInactive
I am a professional still photographer. For the last 7 years I have been also shooting some softball recruiting videos for high school girls. I use Canon Vixia cameras, the hf S10 and the hf S200 with CMOS . Granted I am shooting good light but I have not ever incounted a rolling shutter problem.
I have a couple photographer friends that are no hooting video with a Nikon D4 that blows away 3 CCD chip cameras.
If you are in low light for your filming you probably want to go qith a 3 CCD camera/
January 2, 2013 at 3:49 PM #205487HappyCatFilmsMember
I've done lots of MMA shooting and produced firearm and martial art training vids. The other comments here are good – just offering my $0.02.
Most modern cameras are very, very good, and can produce great results so long as you know and work with their strenghs and weaknesses. That said, no one camera is perfect for every job – each job requires a tool suited to the job.
Some things to consider:
1. Will you shoot run&gun of live events or planned, scripted educational footage?
2. Are you willing to spend time capturing from tape, or is instant editing important to you?
Your choices will be around:
Tape or card-based?
If you will shoot run&gun, even a tricked out DSLR is an exercise in frustration. A dedicated video camera doesn't offer the same beautiful shallow depth of field, but is a lot easier to manage when the action is moving around quickly. Additionally, a tape-based camera can just run and record for the full duration of the tape (1 hour per MiniDV on my Sony HVR-V1U, which I still use regularly). Tapes are very cheap and provide an immediate and complete backup of your footage.
If you need immediate editing and very fast transfer of footage into your editing bay, you may consider a file-based camera. You will have to figure out a data management and backup strategy, and high-capacity cards can get expensive. Some may time out and stop recording due to heat generation, as well.
In my opinion, there is no longer a compelling reason to buy a DSLR if video is your goal. There are several much better choices suited to the particulars of video versus still shooting.
December 27, 2012 at 6:15 PM #205388
That's a nice video, good depth of field – something very important for parents of those kids in background ;), and as I see no problems with sharpness, even with black Gis. My expertise ends here, but it's enough to convince me that it's a good camera for me. I've been looking also at Panasonic AG-AC90P, but has this different sensor-3MOS, I have to find out more about it… Do you know someone using this one in martial arts/sports videos?
thank you for both your comments 🙂
December 27, 2012 at 6:51 PM #205389
Could you define/show what CMOS can do wrong? I was looking yesterday at Panasonic AG-AC90P and I like it too, but as I said I can't try out any camera out here, your comment scared me a bit 😉 (this one has sensor called BSI 3MOS, so I assume it works similarly to CMOS). Thank you for information 🙂
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.