Videomaker – Learn video production and editing, camera reviews › Forums › General › Video and Film Discussion › Audio & Video out of Sync
- This topic has 2 replies, 1 voice, and was last updated 7 years ago by Anonymous.
June 6, 2014 at 2:40 AM #78411AnonymousInactive
firstly, I am a complete beginner to video editing. So I downloaded trial version of both Corel Videostudio X7 and also PowerDirector12. Currently using Corel.
So I transferred my HD camcorder clips onto the PC, which were saved on the PC as default file type .MTS
I then imported them all into Corel, did all my editing and got my final view of my video. When I watch this back on the preview screen in the software on both Corel and Powerdirector, the audio and video are perfectly in sync.
Then comes the issue. I have tried burning to AVCHD (dvd disc) and also DVD disc. Also tried creating files MPEG2 and MT2 on the PC. Whatever I create, the audio becomes out of sync with the video every time (no matter if I use Corel or PowerDirector to burn).
I have googled this and I am struggling to know the best way to fix this. I have tried a piece of software called Womble, which has GOP fixing (no idea if this is the actual issue or not… just guessing). It found 9000 odd errors on the MPEG file I created and "fixed them", but the fixed version is still the same.
So I guess my questions are:
1. why has it done this? Did I do something wrong?
2. Should I not edit MTS files directly? Should I be converting them somehow first? Will I be able to maintain the HD level quality if I convert them?
3. What is the best process to follow when using MTS files and one of the "consumer" editing packages?
4. Is there anyway to fix my current project or do I simply have to start my project again but use converted files?
I dont want to start the project again, but I will if there is a guaranteed fix around this to stop it happening in future projects I do. It is so frustrating that the audio and video goes out of sync after all the hard work editing it. When editing I will always be taking videos from my Panasonic HD Camcorder, so generally it will always default to .MTS
Appreciate any guidance on this as I am a complete beginner. Thanks guys,
June 11, 2014 at 6:12 PM #210578Laguna HikerMember
MTS is a format generally known as Panasonic P2. It's a very good format, but very finnicky. If you haven't erased your P2 cards, try recopying everything on the card (not just the MTS files) to your edit workstation. That may help.
The video editing software you mentioned is fairly low-end consumer software, and MTS is a professional format. The software may not be able to handle it. For editing P2 footage, I generally recommend either Apple Final Cut Pro or Adobe Premiere Pro. There are other good professional-level editing apps out there as well.
Finally, another alternative is to buy an inexpensive video conversion app to convert your MTS footage into something your current editing app can handle, like Quicktime or MP4. There are a lot of conversion apps out there, and many run under $50.
June 12, 2014 at 4:55 PM #210589BernardParticipant
I've been using Power Director (now ver. 12) for long a time and never had such bad results.
It's possibly your hardware (pc) not rendering properly your mts files?
With Power Director 12 I've burned MP4, H.264 on BD. No problems.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.