Solving a lighting problem

Viewing 1 reply thread
  • Author
    • #49667

      I just came back from a 5 hour shoot — interviews shot in the vary spacious bedroom of a wealthy client. The room was very well lit with afternoon natural lighting coming in through the east-facing windows, camera right. The people being interviewed were well lit on the window side, somewhat in shadow on the camera-left side, the side away from the windows.

      We tried using a reflector to bounce light from the window onto the shadowed side: window=key light, reflected (bounced) light=fill light. Back light coming from the windows, bouncing off the light tan wall behind the person being interviewed. Not enough fill, though. What to do?

      We used a small dimmable camera light — an NRG on-camera fixture — on a low light stand, dimmed way down to create fill. Problem was, of course that the daylight side looked slightly blue/cold and the dimmed down light on camera left looked warm.

      We solved this by putting a small bed-side lamp on a low table next to the client on camera left and turned it on with a low wattage bulb. This gave just enough light to show that the lamp was turned on; it cast a nice pool of light onto the table and side of the chair and motivated the slightly warm light on the client’s face. We made sure to show the lamp at the beginning of each interview, just to remind the viewer that there was a warm light source next to the chair.

      Once we balanced the daylight (key) and incandescent light (fill) the scene looked very good and completely believable.

      The lesson to be learned here is one that film makers learned in the early days of film production: if you provide motivation for light by showing a source point — a lamp, street light, flickering candle or fire, etc., almost anything you do with light and shadow that follows will appear believable. 20th century film noire gaffers and DPs used this principle in virtually every film.

      Maybe you’ve had similar work-around experiences with lighting that you can share.


    • #203234

      If you are using some DOF you can get away with two different temps of color. Sometimes you just have to get your subject further away from the cool blue background and it just helps them “Pop” out from it. Then “Temp” or color of the background blends in with its texture. Though it does work best with medium or close-up shots where less is shown of the background.

      But there is a difference between making your subject “Pop” or standout from the background and then “Alienating” them from the background where showing the differing light source would be a must to make it logical to the audience and “sell” it.

      Also location can have influence, like you can pull it off in the woods in the early morning or evening during “Grey” light if they are sitting by a camp fire or in a coffee shop lit by a table light. Or a mechanic under a car lit by a work light but in these cases I think it would be best to show the light source but its also an easy sell. In these cases it would be almost expected.

Viewing 1 reply thread
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Best Products

The best laptops for video editing — 2021

For video editors, finding the perfect portable workstation is like catching a unicorn. It is no easy task to find the perfect balance of performance vs price point.