SD in 16:9

Viewing 4 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #49328
      Avatarbarnacle
      Participant

       I have a consumer grade Panasonic PV-GS90P camcorder.  One of the setup options on it is aspect ratio 16:9 or 4:3.  I’ve always had it set on 4:3 and always had standard definition televisions in the house.  We now have two high definition TVs.  Is there any pluses or minuses to changing the aspect ratio to 16:9?  Am I taking the same number of pixels and spreading them out?  This is a newbie question but that’s how guys like me learn.  From the pros.

      Thank you

    • #202003
      AvatarRob
      Participant

      The difference is your 16:9 footage will be enlarged and fill your HD screen completely. With 4:3 footage, the image is enlarged, but black bars remain on the sides because the aspect ratio don’t match.

      I don’t think there is a difference in quality. I believe both the 4:3 and 16:9 footage are upscaled equally. But the upscaled 16:9 is probably more pleasing to look at.

    • #202004
      Avatardoublehamm
      Participant

      Depends on the camera. If it is scaling to 740×480 for 16:19 it is a good thing (DVD quality). Some cameras actually chop pixels off the 640×480 SD footage to make it 16:9. If this is the case, I would stick with 4:3

    • #202005
      Avatarbarnacle
      Participant

      I made a 20 sec vid of the front yard in 16:9 and a 20 sec vid of the back yard in 4:3.  Captured them in Adobe Premiere Elements 8 and rendered as an MPEG2 and save to a USB drive.  Plugged the USB drive into the HDTV and played it.  Other than the change of scene (front yard to back) I could not tell a difference between the two clips.

      Thanks for the input and I guess I’ll leave the aspect ratio at 4:3.

    • #202006
      Avatartheonecanoe
      Participant

      Bill Dillon writes, “Thanks for the input and I guess I’ll leave the aspect ratio at 4:3.” Bill, if you could not see the difference between the two clips, then why leave it at 4:3 and have to view everything with those black bars on the sides?The future is widescreen. Set that thing to 16:9 and enjoy the full picture!

      Wayne

Viewing 4 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Best Products

The best 360 cameras available — 2021

360-degree video is a brand new medium driven by new 360 camera technology. However, its immersive qualities create unique technological challenges.
homicide-bootstrap