Please help me chose JVC GY-HD200U vs Canon XL H1

Videomaker – Learn video production and editing, camera reviews Forums General Video and Film Discussion Please help me chose JVC GY-HD200U vs Canon XL H1

Viewing 3 reply threads
  • Author
    • #43564

      I am planing to buy an HDV camera, but hesitating between JVC GY-HD200U and Canon XL H1. Your input will help me. Thanks! Ike

    • #182726

      Let me start by saying I’ve never operated either camcorder (how’s that for building your confidence in my response! X-D ).
      By I’ve read lots of reviews of those camcorders (and I did stay at a Holiday Inn last night πŸ˜€ ).

      OK, joking aside, the reviews say the Canon shoots 1080 interlaced scan, and has the best resolution in its price range. The Canon has HD-SDI output, which woud be useful if you ever want to record uncompressed video to an external device. Otherwise, either camcorder will be recording in HDV, which is highly compressed, thus introducing artifacts.

      The JVC shoots 720 progresive scan, and has among the best resolution for camcorders shooting at 720p. Also, reviewers have commented on how much they like the layout of the controls on the JVC.

      Bottom line: Both are excellent HDV camcorders. Choose the JVC for the most comfortable, enjoyable shooting experience (all the controls right where you want them), and to get progressive scan. Or choose the Canon for the highest resolution in this price range, and to have the option for recording uncompressed video (when appropriate devices become available).

      My own preference would be for the JVC, but I would totally understand someone choosing the Canon. (Actually, when I move to HD, I’ll probably go with a Panasonic HVX200, but that’s another story. πŸ˜‰ )

      Have fun with whatever you get!
      Ken Hull

    • #182727

      Dear Experienced,
      may I know does it require specially equiped powerful computers to capture and edit the full HD output from Canon XH G1? What device is needed to transfer the full HD output to a computer for postproduction? Please, thank you.

    • #182728

      one more question – ???
      is there any decks like the Sony dcr 70 that can read HDV tapes recorded from a Canon XH G1?
      is it better to use the similar decks for capturing instead of directly via the camera? Thanks again and appreciate any comments whatsoever. πŸ˜€

Viewing 3 reply threads
  • The forum ‘Video and Film Discussion’ is closed to new topics and replies.

Best Products

The best laptops for video editing β€” 2021

For video editors, finding the perfect portable workstation is like catching a unicorn. It is no easy task to find the perfect balance of performance vs price point.



Given away to one lucky winner

Competition is open worldwide


Need help making a stellar first video?


Download our free eBook with 8 tips to get on the right track and create a video that you can be proud of.