Videomaker – Learn video production and editing, camera reviews › Forums › General › Video and Film Discussion › Mixing HD & SD?
- August 4, 2007 at 5:43 PM #43579LeofriedParticipant
I am planning to use two cameras on a documentary. My Sony VX2100 is SD, my HVR-V1U is HD. Does anyone out there have experience with mixing these formats?
By the way, I just joined the forum and this is my first post. I’ve had a very productive afternoon browsing through the topics. I hope that I can give as well as get. Although I might be a relative ‘noobie’ to video, I was trained in motion picture production, and I might know a thing or two that will prove helpful to others.
- August 5, 2007 at 12:02 PM #182781maxheadspaceParticipant
This is totally dependent on the non linear editor that you use. I use Premiere Pro 2, and it does a fine job of mixing these formats. I am mixing both SD and HDV, as well as 720P HDV with 1080i HDV. The SD and HDV should mix fine. I threw together a short vid for my son that had SD and HDV mixed. I shot in 16:9 1080i HDV, and he shot in 4:3 480i SD. When I rendered to SD video file, you couldn’t tell the SD from the HDV. You can view it here: http://one.revver.com/find/user/maxheadspace. It’s the video with the manatees. Where you will have problems is with the size of the screen. If you configure your project for SD, when you import the HDV it will likely appear zoomed in. You will probably have to re-size the HDV clips to make them fit the screen. The reverse is true if you configure the project for HDV; the SD clips will not fill the screen. Then if you use standard 4:3 ratio for SD, and 16:9 ratio for HDV, the sides of your HDV will be clipped off. Most of that should be intuitive.
- August 5, 2007 at 2:03 PM #182782AnonymousInactive
final cut express handles it easily. you simply resize the sd content.
- August 6, 2007 at 10:38 AM #182783LeofriedParticipant
Thanks for your responses! If I knew how to, I would put in a smiley emoticon, but I’ve got enough to learn right now. When I posted the question I was thinking about differences in resolution, not in size. Now I’ll be ready to cross that bridge when I come to it.
If FC express will handle mixing both formats, then FC Studio ought to.
By the way, I think I noticed ;0)’s name in a reply to a post about mixing interior and exterior light. You gave some good advice.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.