William — I edit on a Windows Vista machine too. I take the SD card out of my DSLR and put it directly into my computer – no need for firewire. Sounds like you need an SD card camcorder or DSLR. But beyond that, it depends on your shooting style, and ultimately, what you want to see on the screen.
The NEX-VG10 is a great “DSLR in camcorder’s clothing”, and produces cinema-like shallow depth of field with its large APS-C sensor and interchangeable lenses, but it does not have the 1080p video, power zoom, manual audio gain control or XLR inputs that you would expect in a $2000 camcorder. The DSLR-style large sensor and high megapixel count of the VG10 also make it liable to aliasing — crawling colors on shingled roofs and patterned clothing.
If shallow depth-of field and interchangeable lenses are important to you, get the VG10. But if you want crystal clear 1080p video, a power zoom, manual audio gain and built-in pro XLR inputs, I suggest the Canon XA10.
You can spend less on something like a Sony HDR-CX560V, a Panasonic TM-900 or even a DSLR like the Panasonic GH2 (and still make great short films), but the XA10 gives you a pro quality camcorder for less than $2000.
Bill
.
