HP ZBook 17 G2 Review

HP ZBook 17 G2

The HP ZBook 17 G2 is a feature-packed mobile workstation designed for the demanding video producer. Equipped with high-end hardware options, including a calibrated wide-gamut monitor, this laptop attempts to compete with some of the best video production desktops. We put the ZBook through its paces to see just how useful it is at both getting work done and being mobile. 

The HP ZBook line is a “no compromises” approach to delivering professional workstation-class performance in a portable size. For this review, we had the pleasure of testing the ZBook 17 G2, outfitted with many top-tier options. This is a product designed for the most demanding professional user in mind and would certainly deliver in video production, animation or engineering. The ZBook has USB 3.0, Thunderbolt and SD Card for input, so you'll never have trouble getting content onto it, and when you need more storage or memory, it has two extra SATA storage and memory slots easily accessible from the underside. Upgrading storage or memory is literally as easy as changing the battery pack. With the fastest WiFi at the time of this writing and the option for LTE wireless service, you can be guaranteed the fastest internet connection possible for uploading whatever content you produce at home, work, or on the go.

A Look Inside

The model we reviewed was the ZBook 17 G2 which came equipped with an Intel i7 4940MX quad core CPU with hyperthreading for 8 processing threads at 3.1GHz all the way up to 4.0GHz, an Nvidia Quadro K5100M graphics, 16GB of 1600MHz RAM, a 512GB SSD connected directly on the PCIe bus for maximum throughput and an HP Dreamcolor display touted to provide the most accurate color rendition available. The back of the screen and the underside of the chassis are black metal and the rest of the laptop is a sturdy black plastic that feels surprisingly tough. There's nearly zero flex to the lid when you open it, but the hinge is tight and may require two hands to pry the screen off the keys without the whole thing lifting off your work surface — which may seem surprising given that the whole package weighs in at a hefty 8 pounds. The keyboard consists of flat, back-lit keys and features a number pad. There is a multi-touch track pad below the keys as well as a track-point in the center of the keys. There is a biometric security scanner and hardware toggles for mute and Wi-Fi for added convenience.

The most important features of this product are undoubtedly the massive processing power in both the CPU and the Nvidia Quadro graphics.

The most important features of this product are undoubtedly the massive processing power in both the CPU and the Nvidia Quadro graphics. Having a fast CPU has obvious benefits, but less understood are the benefits of a fast OpenCL and CUDA supporting GPU. For applications that support it, offloading rendering and other power intensive processes from the four cores on the CPU to the 1536 cores on the GPU can have massive gains in speed. Applications such as Adobe CS and CC, Sony Vegas, Final Cut Pro and many other popular editing suites support this functionality and will take full advantage of this power.

Performance

Because the review unit was running Windows via the 512 GB SSD, boot sequence was a quick 15 seconds from the time we pushed the power button until we heard the Windows start sound. The screen is bright and is easy to see in every setting short of direct sunlight. We did notice that the backlight driver made a faint high pitch squeal, noticeable only in dead silence, which varied with the brightness setting. This was a minor annoyance.

The first test we performed was benchmarking. PC Mark in the "HP Recommended" power setting yielded a “Home” score of 4038, a “Creative” score of 3328, and a “Work” score of 3537. Turning the Windows power setting up to "High Performance" served up scores of 4190, 3488 and 3620 respectively. Catzilla earned a score of 14390 at 576p. CineBench reported 140.34 fps in OpenGL and a CPU score of 721 cb.

The next test we performed was data transfers and media transcoding. We copied the contents of a 6.84 GB DVD from my external hard drive via USB 3.0 to the SSD. This transfer took about 60 seconds at a rate of about 90 MB/sec. Using Handbrake, we transcoded the DVD into H.264 using the “high profile” preset, which took only 17 minutes. Copying the finished 1.21 GB file back to my external drive took only 16.6 seconds.

For the last series of tests, we wanted to see how battery life is during a range of usage scenarios, which was accomplished by running the battery empty from full charge. The low usage scenario consisted of browsing the web and catching up on social media, during which the battery held out for three hours and 25 minutes. Next, I wanted to see if I could stream, at the very least, a full movie from Netflix, so I started playing a season of “Friends”, which it continued to play for two hours and 40 minutes — in other words, probably, depending on the movie. Finally, I tested full utilization of both CPU and GPU with the screen on full brightness, in order to simulate the most intensive usage imaginable, which it handled for more than 50 minutes until the system shut down.

Conclusions

Given its weight, bulky size, and less-than-ideal battery life, the HP ZBook 17 G2 is hardly a laptop computer and much more a mobile workstation. It could comfortably replace a desktop workstation using the HP docking station, where one could connect a 4K monitor, quality speakers, and a conventional mouse and keyboard. There is also the option for an external 9-cell/100 WHr battery, which will more than double your available power while unplugged. Battery life aside, with its sturdy construction, top-of-the-line processor, unbeatable graphics and display, easy access for upgrades and drive swapping, plus a wide variety of super fast data connections, the HP ZBook 17 G2 doesn’t need to fight for a place at the top — this workstation stands at the pinnacle of mobile computing.

Strengths:

  • Fast processing and graphics
  • Factory calibrated wide-gamut monitor
  • Great input and outputs
  • Easy to upgrade

Weakness:

  • Battery life
  • Large and heavy
  • Monitor makes a faint, but noticeable, sound

Tech Specs as tested:

CPU: Intel i7 4940MX Quad-core @ 3.1GHz and Turbo Boost up to 4GHz
RAM: 16GB (4 DIMM x 4GB) 1600MHz, 2 DIMM slots accessible via lower panel
Graphics: Nvidia Quadro K5100M
Storage: 512GB SSD on PCIe, 2x SATA drive bays, all accessible via lower panel
Connections: 3 USB 3.0, 1 USB 2.0, LAN, Displayport 1.2, VGA, Thunderbolt 2, SD Card, Smart Card, Expresscard, Cable Lock, Headset (stereo out + mic in), Lower HP Dock port, Lower External Battery Port, Sim Card
Operating System: Windows 7
Optical Drive: Blu Ray + DVD+/-RW SuperMulti DL
Wireless: Intel 7260NGW 802.11 a/b/g/n/ac 2x2, Bluetooth 4.0 LE, HSPA+ and LTE
Monitor: 17-inch HP Dreamcolor Wide Gamut Factory Calibrated, 1920x1080 native resolution
Weight: ~8 lbs
Dimensions: 16.37 x 10.7 x 1.33 in
Battery: 8 Cell 83 WHr

Brandon received a BS in Physics from Sac State and has over 15 years of computer science experience. He currently resides in Chico, CA.

Issue: 

Brandon
Bentley
Tue, 11/03/2015 - 9:28am

Comments

laptop supporting 'lagacy' tape shooters

I understand legacy with cars - even though I know every performance parameter is compromised I choose to not care that I don't even have fuel-injection - disk brakes
let-alone air bags and every other safety advance ---- but shooting with tape means getting rejected for any job where clients have the right to expect modern camera quality --- a 2016 Sony AX53 consumer handycam for less than 1k kills any of my former pro cameras --- except that they do have much nicer cases that are worth more than the cameras

HP ZB00k i7 G2

memorris1's picture

I have researched this product per this review but have been unable to find a model number that matches the test specs for the $1,750 price. Could someone please provide me with this info (model #) so that I might purchase this product.
Thank you.
Mike - silversmith2005@comcast.net

HP ZBOOK 17 G2 REVIEW

1. No price was mentioned. Research shows it to be near 2k but I don't know if that is set-up as this one was.
2. Windows 7 ?
3. What are the 4k editing performance stats ?
For comparison pricing my 4 year-old Dell i5 Vostro 18" screen cost $900 new and needed $700 more to upgrade with the SSD - 16g - better video card so 2k for a newer faster i7 built for video seems reasonable if that is "As Tested" pricing.