Roxio Creator 2011 Introductory Editing Software Review

Roxio Creator 2011 Introductory Editing Software Review

The venerable Roxio Creator digital media suite provides extensive support for working with video, photos, music and audio, and disc backup and burning.

With past new consumer electronics technologies, such as DVD, DV, and HD, the trickle down from professional production to affordable consumer gear took years and years - as these were first deployed for movie and broadcast production, then for corporate and independents, until finally becoming affordable for consumers and enthusiasts.

This was still true with the more recent introduction of Blu-ray discs, as you still need professional tools to take advantage of the advanced programmability of the format, and even basic Blu-ray authoring with consumer-range tools requires additional licensing fees.

So you might expect the same situation with the latest greatest innovation in the consumer electronics - 3D technology. The CE industry began the push to 3D in 2010, starting at usual at the high end, with top-of-the-line 3D HDTVs and early 3D Blu-ray players, supported by expensive production work at high-profile sporting events and for Hollywood blockbusters.

Instead, perhaps because 3D was already well understood from the PC gaming side, the trickle down has taken less than a year - as 3D capabilities are already appearing in even entry-level consumer products like the new Roxio Creator 2011 media suite, released in August 2010 for $100.

If you want 3D, Creator 2011 has it in spades - You can import, edit, and export 3D video productions and slide shows and discs, in standard-def and HD, and in a variety of common 3D formats, for display on 3D TVs and PC 3D displays, and sharing on YouTube.

Even better, Creator even can get you started with 3D without needing to buy new equipment:

  • You don't need a new display - Creator supports anaglyph (red/blue) 3D on standard displays (TV or PC), which you can view with simple cardboard glasses (one set is even included with the product).
  • You don't need new cameras for 3D content - While you can import material from enthusiast 3D cameras like the Fujifilm FinePix Real 3D W3 Digital Camera (around $500 street), Creator also can convert standard 2D photos and 2D videos to 3D, so you can "dimensionalize" your existing 2D material into 3D productions.
  • And you don't even need to create a 3D production - Creator can play your existing 2D videos and "dimensionalize" them into 3D on the fly.

Roxio Streamer

Beyond 3D, the other big news with Creator 2011 is the new Roxio Streamer application, which opens up your PC (or Mac) as a media server, to share your files not only on your home network, but also across the Internet for sharing through a Web browser (using Adobe Flash), with password security.

As a home media server, Roxio Streamer allows you to access your PC media files from other PCs on your home network, and from consumer electronics devices that support DLNA sharing, including TVs, set-top DVD players, and game systems like the Sony PS3.

Creator 2011

Beyond the new 3D and the media server, Creator 2011 is an evolutionary update to the Roxio Creator line, which Roxio reports is the leading toolset for digital media. This year's edition adds new refinements including video stabilization, especially for shaky pocket camcorders, and video rotation, especially for digital camera videos. It expands sharing with portable devices including the iPad, and Web sharing with direct publishing to Facebook. And it provides faster processing with acceleration for the latest Intel i7 and i9 processors and ATI Stream and NVIDIA CUDA graphics.

Creator 2011 continues the well-designed look and key application components of the 2010 version. It supports the full range of media - video, audio, photos, and data - for importing, editing, and sharing, on PCs, portable devices, online, and on disc. And Creator supports a wide variety of popular media files and formats, including HD, H.264, AVCHD, and Blu-ray disc (as a separate plug-in).

The Roxio Creator 2011 Pro bundle for $130 adds Blu-ray Disc authoring and additional applications, including Roxio Secure Burn for disc backup and encryption, SmartSound Sonicfire Pro for custom soundtracks, Bias SoundSoap SE for noise reduction, and BackOnTrack for backup and disaster recovery.

The Roxio Creator 2011 application provides a launch pad for accessing the different capabilities of the suite. You select the media type you want to work with (Data, Video, Audio, Photo), and then choose the task to perform on that media, grouped by category (Import, Edit, Create, Enjoy). For help getting started, use the Learning Center with an expanded selection of video tutorials that demonstrate specific tasks. Most also have accompanying step-by-step PDF instructions.

3D Video

For video editing, Creator includes the venerable VideoWave application, plus CineMagic to automatically generate movies from video clips and photos, and MyDVD to author projects to disc. Or use the assistants for more focused tasks, including Video Copy & Convert to copy entire DVDs, or create video compilations to files, disc, and portable devices.

To work with 3D video, both VideoWave and MyDVD can import video in a variety of 3D formats, as well as convert 2D video to 3D - to preview, edit, enhance, and author in 3D. Or upload to YouTube to view online in 3D. However, not all editing options are available in 3D, including stabilization and rotation effects. It's also best to avoid effects that distort the video, blur edges, or adjust colors (for anaglyph) - which can lessen the 3D effect.

With MyDVD, you can author 3D DVDs in anaglyph or RealD format, albeit without menus (but with chapters). You even can author 3D in high definition, and burn in AVCHD format to a standard DVD, which will play in HD on Blu-ray players.

To view 3D video, CinePlayer not only plays 3D videos, but it also converts 2D standard-def video to 3D - in real time. It supports a variety of display formats, including active shutter, line polarized, and anaglyph. You also can adjust the 3D format during playback, including the 3D depth and position.

3D Photos

For photo editing, use PhotoSuite to repair, enhance, and share digital photos.Plus there are a variety of assistant tools to enhance photos, create slideshows and other collections, and upload online.

Creator 2011 does not support editing photos in 3D space (i.e., in PhotoSuite). Instead, the new Create 3D Photos application allows you to view a photo in 3D and adjust the stereo positioning before exporting. It imports photos in three formats:

  • 3D photo formats - Including side by side and the MPO format from Fujifilm FinePix Real 3D digital cameras.
  • Photo pairs taken with a standard camera - Made by moving the camera a few inches between shots to simulate human stereo vision
  • Standard 2D photos - which can be converted into 3D You then can export individual photos in a variety of 3D formats to show on the compatible displays. You also can create a 3D slideshow, or import 3D photos into VideoWave and MyDVD to include in your video productions.

Suite

If you're interested in experimenting with 3D productions, Roxio Creator 2011 is ready with an inexpensive and comprehensive solution. This is not only amazingly soon after the introduction of the first high-end products, but also impressively complete, in terms of supporting a range of common formats, and in providing 2D to 3D conversion so you can get going out of the box, with no additional equipment cost. So step out of the plane, and get dimensionalized.

Tech Specs

Input Formats:
Video: AVI, DV, HDV, DV-AVI, MKV, MPEG-1/2/4, MPEG2-HD, DVD-Video, IFO/VOB, XviD, DVR-MS, TiVo, ASF, MOV, WMV, QuickTime, 3GP, MPEG2 Transport Stream, AVC (H.264), AVCHD
Audio: Audio CD, MP3, WAV, WMA, Dolby® Digital AC-3, AAC, Ogg Vorbis, FLAC, M4A, MP4, Playlists (WPL, ASX, M3U, PLS, XSPF)
Image: MPO, JPG, PNG, TIFF, BMP, GIF Output Formats: Video: AVI, DV-AVI, HDV, MPEG-1/2/4, MPEG2-HD, , WMV, WMV HD, AVC (H.264), MP4, 3GP
Output Formats:
Audio: MP3, WAV, WMA, Dolby Digital AC-3, Ogg Vorbis, FLAC, MPEG-1/2, M4A, M4B AAC, Playlists (M3U, PLS, XSPF, WPL)
Image: JPG, PNG, TIFF, BMP, GIF
Video disc formats: DVD, Video CD(VCD), Super Video CD (SVCD), Mini DVD 3D
3D video input formats: over/under full and half height, side-by-side full and half width, anaglyph red/cyan, RealD, Fuji FinePix REAL 3D
3D video output formats: anaglyph red/cyan, side-by-side and full and half-width, over/under full and half height, RealD
Recordable Formats: CD-R/RW, DVD+R/RW, DVD-R/RW, DVD-R DL, DVD+R DL, DVD-RAM, BD-R/RE, BD-R/RE DL

Sidebar: 3D Displays and Formats

Watching 3D media, as with high-def / widescreen content, requires two elements: a compatible display that supports the technology, and content stored in a compatible format. As a result, Creator supports importing and exporting a variety of 3D video and photo formats, as well as a range of display formats for preview and playback.

Creator supports editing previews and CinePlayer playback using a variety of 3D display hardware technologies, including real-time adjustments:

  • Anaglyph - with red/cyan glasses (for use on standard monitors)
  • Polarized LCD - Polarized screens with passive polarized glasses (as often used in movie theaters)
  • Active shutter - 3D HDTVs / NVIDIA 3D Vision with active shutter glasses (battery powered)

For importing and exporting 3D content, Creator supports a variety of formats for storing a pair of stereo images. This can be done with formats that explicitly store separate left and right images (as with the MPO Multi-Picture photo format, used by the Fujifilm FinePix Real 3D digital cameras), or with formats that store both images in the same frame (i.e., side-by-side or top/bottom):

  • Anaglyph red/cyan
  • Side-by-side left/right and right/left - full and half width
  • Top/bottom left/right and right/left - full and half width
  • MPO - Fujifilm FinePix REAL 3D digital cameras
  • RealD (used by most 3D TVs)

You can choose the appropriate compatible formats for previewing on your PC display, or for exporting a production to be viewed on a target system like a 3D HDTV. Creator also provides options for specifying the format details of imported 3D media, and tweaking the display format for better depth perception.

Strengths

  • Venerable digital media suite with strong core products for video, photos, audio, and discs
  • Wide range of options for sharing media on disc, including direct capture and compilations
  • Focused assistant applications for specific tasks, especially for capturing and converting music
  • Extensive new support for getting started with 3D video and photos
  • Helpful refinements for smaller camcorders and cameras, including video stabilization and video rotation
  • Expanded Learning Center with video demos and printable step-by-steps
  • Adds Roxio Streamer to access your media over your home network and the Internet

Weaknesses

  • Can be confusing to understand which tool to use for what, and what each tool can do
  • Lots of individual tools to understand and learn (30+)
  • Different tools accessed in different ways
  • Blu-ray authoring at additional cost

Summary

The venerable Roxio Creator digital media suite provides extensive support for working with video, photos, music and audio, and disc backup and burning.

Roxio
455 El Camino Real
Santa Clara, CA 95050
www.roxio.com
$100

Doug Dixon covers digital media at Manifest-Tech.com.

Issue: 

Douglas
Dixon
Sat, 01/01/2011 - 12:00am