You are here

Canon XA25 Professional Camcorder Review

Canon XA25 Professional Camcorder
The Canon XA25 is a compact, “run-n-gun” professional camcorder that offers outstanding image quality, dual simultaneous recording formats, infrared night shooting, an HD/SD-SDI port for uncompressed output, with dual XLR ports and full manual controls for use with professional microphones.
 
The XA25 dual-recording format, high definition camcorder from Canon was conceived with the action-hungry professional in mind. Light on heft, but not on features, the XA25 is built to run-n-gun with the best of them. Whether packing in to the remotest of locations or army crawling through hordes of paparazzi standing between you and your next news story, the diminutive size and excellent recording capabilities of the XA25 make it the perfect shooting companion.
 

New Arrival

The XA25 comes with the usual items such as a lens hood (with manually operated flip-up lens barrier), battery pack, wireless controller, and cables for USB 2.0, RCA and Mini HDMI. One super-nifty extra that puts the XA25 a few steps higher on the “oh yeah” scale is the microphone holder/handle unit. It attaches to the shoe mount at the front with a pair of screws and a multi-interface shoe at the rear. With the audio handle attached,  it serves double duty as both a carry point and is home to a pair of XLR microphone ports and their controls. 
 

Up Close and Personal

With the form factor of a compact camcorder, the XA25 utilizes a fixed Canon lens with 20x optical zoom to perform its magic. Focusable to just about two feet and with a zoom range of 26.8mm – 576mm (35mm equivalent) the XA25 offers the user a great deal of versatility. Stabilizing and focusing functions are virtually silent, while zooming produces sound that is barely detectable, with only a very slight hum noticeable in the otherwise quiet places.
 
There are few buttons on the XA25 since most features are accessed through the touch sensitive LCD screen and menu system. A CUSTOM dial and button beneath the lens may be set to Tv (adjust shutter)/Av (adjust aperture), Manual Exposure, AGC Limit, Exposure Lock or Off. Five additional user-programmable buttons are available, two of which reside on the bezel of the LCD display. One is preset to switch between Auto and Manual focus while the other accesses the pre-record function.
 
Even though buttons are few, full manual control is achievable. Focus assist features include 2x image magnification and color peaking in your choice of red, blue or yellow highlights. While there is no histogram, two zebra settings at 70 percent and 100 percent help to get the exposure just right.
Dual SD Card Slots and Infrared Switch
   
Behind the LCD are the infrared on/off switch and the dual SD card slots with protective sliding cover. Infrared is a fun feature that records that almost surreal, funky-eyed, green or black and white look, that is seen in many a horror movie, and useful when shooting in very low light situations. Dual card slots provide a great deal of versatility by allowing you to record to two cards at the same time for instant file backups. Or, you can record longer by choosing Relay Recording automatically switching from one card to the other when the first one is full. You can even capture footage in the AVCHD recording format to one card while simultaneously capturing the MP4 recording format to the other.
 
A switch at the rear changes the lens ring to control either zoom or focus. Zoom control with the ring probably won't be necessary though, as there is a zoom rocker on the right side of the camera and another on top of the detachable handle. Speaking of switches, the battery release is a bit of an issue when the XA25 is perched atop a tripod because the adapter plate will cover the release switch – requiring the camera to be removed from the tripod in order to swap out the battery.
Inputs and outputs, including HD/SDI
 
The FUNC and navigation buttons at the rear allow you to access Function and Menu settings without having to get fingerprints all over the LCD panel. A switch next to the main optical zoom rocker lets you choose between full auto, full manual or CINEMA mode. Input and output options include AV out, headphones, Mini-B USB, Mini HDMI, remote, an HD/SD-SDI BNC connector for uncompressed 1920x1080 and 4:2:2 color output as well as an external microphone 1/8-inch jack.
 
Now if the 1/8-inch jack just isn't enough, the handle incorporates dual locking XLR ports on the right side, with line, mic, phantom power and gain controls on the opposite. Above the mic ports is a detachable flexible shock mount for carrying a quality shotgun microphone. While the onboard mic is fine for non-professional use, handling noise is certainly an issue. For pro applications, getting the mic up and away from the camera is always the best approach. This feature alone indicates the XA25 isn't your run-of-the-mill camcorder. 
 

On The Road Again

Anxious to try out the XA25's color reproduction prowess, we headed out to a nearby historic home and garden area. Happily, the Canon glass, imaging sensor and DIGIC DV 4 processing engine didn’t let us down in the least. We captured our footage using the AVCHD recording format but MP4 is an option as well. Whether dark green stems and leaves or bright orange and yellow blossoms, colors were vivid, true and breathtaking. The XA25's HD image quality is excellent. (See our video tests at: www.videomaker.com/r/654.)
   
Next, an amazing old cork tree and polished inlaid stone bench gave us the opportunity to check out the XA25's ability to handle textures and fine details. Again, we were not disappointed. The rugged exterior of the cork tree, with all its cavernous cracks and crevices, bumps and striations is visible right down to the smallest detail. The polished rock of the bench holds no secrets either as the individual particles within the mortar and even the smallest of insects running frantically back and forth across its surface are captured.
Broad Dynamic Range Test
 
Numerous scenes depicting both deep darks and very bright areas show the broad dynamic range of the XA25. Digital can't touch film in this respect but the XA25 certainly does a very fine job.
 
Because of the way CMOS sensors capture images, rolling shutter, also known as “the jelly effect,” is an issue for any camcorder or DSLR that uses one or more of them. We tested this by panning across a tall communications tower in the distance. As expected, the XA25 also falls victim to this effect. How much? It is probably somewhere in the middle, as we've seen some that are much worse and a few that fared better. Avoid fast pans and vertical structures as much as possible to minimize the effect.
 
As vertical lines can lead to the rolling shutter anomaly, horizontal lines and other fine patterns can sometimes lead to a pair of equally undesirable phenomena known as aliasing (the jaggies) or moiré.  Aliasing occurs when straight lines appear to be jagged and moiré happens when lines appear to interact in such a way that movement and/or new patterns appear. During a drive through a residential area, where houses feature rooftops with horizontal lines, the XA25 demonstrates the effect – noticeable, but comparable to other cameras we've seen in this price range.
 
For our test of the optical image stabilization system we zoomed all the way in on a subject and shot it handheld while remaining as still as possible. We did this with the stabilization turned off and again with it turned on. We then repeated the test while moving slowly forward toward the subject. While stationary, whether standard or dynamic (five-axis) stabilization was used, the result was a much more stable image. The moving test however showed somewhat less dramatic results.
   
The XA25's handle features an infrared emitter and diffuser that lets you capture footage when there is little to no light present. Whether you're shooting in the style of The Blair Witch Project, police reality show or simply traipsing through the boonies without your flashlight, just set the infrared switch to on, select white or green light from the menu and get ready for some night vision.
   
As a final test we “deliberately” shot some underexposed and overexposed footage to see how well the video fares in post. The results were passable considering the detail that is typically lost from over and underexposed footage.
 
The Canon XA25 is a camcorder aimed squarely at the run-n-gun professional. It's compact, lightweight and packed with plenty of pleasing features. 
 
Canon U.S.A., Inc.
www.usa.canon.com
$3,000
 
 

Tech Specs

Model: Canon XA25
Image Sensor: 1/2.84-inch CMOS, RGB Primary Color Filter
Total Pixels: Approx. 3.1 Megapixels (2208x1398)
Effective Pixels: Approx. 2.9 Megapixels (2136x1362)
Zoom Ratio: 20x Optical/400x Digital
Focal Length: 3.7-73.4mm (35mm equivalent: 26.8-576mm without Dynamic IS; 28.8-576mm with Dynamic IS)
Zoom Speed: Variable speed/Constant speed (16 levels); Fast, Normal, Slow
f/Stop: f/1.8-2.8
Focusing System: Hybrid AF; Instant AF; Medium AF; Normal AF; Face Priority AF; Face Only AF; Manual Focus
Manual Exposure: Available
Programmed AE: Smart Auto, P, Tv, Av, Manual, SCN (Portrait, Sports, Night, Snow, Beach, Sunset, Low Light, Spotlight, Fireworks); Cinema Mode: P, Tv, Av, M
Max. Shutter Speed: 1/2000 sec.
Minimum Focusing Distance: 20mm (wide end)/600mm (across entire zooming range)
White Balance: Auto, Set 1, Set 2, color temperature (2000K to 15000K in 100K increments), Daylight, Shade, Cloudy, Tungsten, Fluorescent, Fluorescent H
Frame Rate: NTSC: AVCHD – 1080: 59.94P/59.94i/PF29.97/23.98p; MP4 – 1080: 59.94p/29.97p/23.98p; 720 and 360: 29.97p/23.98p
Video Recording System: MPEG4-AVC/H.264
Audio Recording System: Linear PCM (2ch) (in 28Mb/s/23.98Mb/s recording mode only); Dolby Digital (5.1 ch when SM-V1 is used); resolution: 16 bits
Minimum Illumination: 1.2 lux; Low Light Mode: Approx. 0.1 lux (shutter speed1 /2 ½ sec.)
Image Stabilization: Dynamic SuperRange Optical System (Lens shift), Standard SuperRange Optical System (Lens shift), and electronic stabilization. Available modes: Intelligent IS (AUTO mode), Dynamic IS, Powered IS, Macro IS, Tripod Mode; Standard IS, IS Off
Filter Diameter: 58mm
Viewfinder: 0.2-inch, TFT Widescreen color LCD (equivalent to approx. 1.6 million dots; approx. 100% field of view)
LCD Screen: 3.5” OLED, Capacitive Touch Panel (Approx. 1.2 million dots)
Recording Media: SD/SDHC/SDXC memory card slots (2)
USB Terminal: Hi-Speed Mini-B (output only)
Video Terminal: Composite: A/V terminal, 1/8” (3.5mm mini-jack) output only; BNC terminal, output
Audio Terminal: XLR 3-pin jack (2ch), MIC/LINE switch possible (input only)
HDMI Terminal: HDMI OUT mini connector
Microphone Terminal: 1/8” (3.5mm mini-jack)
AV Mini Terminal/Headphone Terminal: 1/8” (3.5mm mini-jack) 4-pole mini-jack (video/audio output only)
Headphone Terminal: 1/8” (3.5mm mini-jack)
Remote Control Terminal: .1” (2.5mm mini-jack) (input only)
Power Supply (rated): 7.4 VDC (battery pack); 8.4 VDC (DC IN)
Dimensions (WxHxD): 4.3” x 3.3” x 7.2” (not including lens hood, grip belt, microphone holder and handle unit)
Weight: Approx. 1.7 lb. (includes grip belt)
 
Strengths
  • Excellent video quality
  • Highly effective stabilization system
  • Professional XLR mic support
  • Focus-assist options
  • Two zebra levels
  • Simultaneous dual recording format capture
 
Weaknesses
  • Battery release blocked by tripod adapter plate 

 

Contributing Editor Mark Holder is a video producer and trainer. 

Tags:  August 2013
Mark
Holder
Wed, 06/26/2013 - 12:23pm

Comments

Martin Cowan's picture

We have just received our Canon XA25 today and one of the first problems we encountered was how we bring the MP4 (35Mb) footage into a FCP sequence. With the AVCHD there is a plug-in but not for the MP4 files! Next we took a quick look at the FTP upload capability. There does not seem to be a method of selecting individual clips to upload, instead it appears that you have to upload the entire contents of your drive. Well Mr Canon, thats not going to be very practical in a ENG situation when you only want to FTP one grab and a few set ups ! mmm I am starting to think the WiFi / FTP tools on this little camera are just a gimmic and not really intentended for Pro/Broadcast use. Any thoughts on this would be most welcome.

Robert Baker's picture

Interesting complaint (not ready for broadcast use), Martin, but I don't think this camera is targeted for that market. I understand the confusion about an included feature that isn't ready for primetime, that usually annoys me as well. Either include a full feature or leave it out but a crippled feature is more of a nusance. However this could be a case where a firmware upgrade will upgrade that feature. You might want to write to Canon to voice your opinion. 

I am very interested to see if you can get 4.2.2 color  from the HDMI output as well as the HD-SDI output.

Dave514's picture

For the "run and gun" crowd, when actually running, the stabilization on this camera is pathetic. Buy the Sony HXR-NX30U.

Matt Wolfskill's picture

I purchased a Canon XA20 a few weeks ago and have been testing it out.

Everything is performing as expected, except there is an odd "hollow" quality to the sound when I am monitoring on my headphones. It sounds like a slight reverb or echo. Sort of like being in a large, very live room.

I've tried the on-camera mikes and a couple of mounted shotguns using the xlr connection. The echo is still there.

When I transfer the captured video to my computer and listen, the sound is fine -- no "echo."

I am using Sennheiser HD 25 headphones, which I've used for years on other camcorders, so no changes there.

Anyone else hearing this unusual sound quality?

William Tuke's picture

Has anyone any experience of this camera in a low-light situation?  Apart from the IR night scene, which is a different scenario, the VideoMaker video seems to have only covered a nice bright day, where most camera chips work well. It would be good to have say a late evening/night city scene or regularly lit sitting room to evaluate low-light capability. Also, would like to see if it is possible to get any kind of shallow depth-of-field shots as alluded to in Canon's own blurb - quote "Out of focus areas are smoother, more natural and more appealing" (usa canon - xa25 features). The 'jello' test was quite 'gentle' by comparrison to other such tests that I've seen with other cameras and on other review sites. VM's might be more realistic which was good, but you need to do both. I would like to see VM's review videos being a bit more thorough for the sake of its readers. 

I contacted Canon Tech Support and explained that, when monitoring a recording with headphones, there is a slight delay in the sound. It is a little "behind" the video.

 

I explained this slight delay was present in both mono and stereo mode, using either the built-in mics or external shotguns. So, regardless of the source, it's still there.

 

On playback, the slight delay is gone. The video and audio match and are in sync.

 

I told her I'm using Sennheiser HD 25 headphones, which I have had for years, and never heard this slight delay on other videocams when recording.

 

The tech suggested I try another pair of headphones, which I did, but that didn't change the outcome. There was still that slight delay.

 

The XA20 has only been available for a few weeks and Canon probably doesn't have a whole lot of feedback from other owners at this point.

 

It will be interesting to see if others notice this unusual sound quality in their headphones and contact Canon.

 

In the meantime, if anyone has some suggestions or solutions, please let me know.

cinemapete's picture

As some readers have pointed out, VM could have included a bit more comprehensive tests.  The example video posted to Vimeo has lots of issues with it image quality-wise; don't know if it's a problem with the orignal video or the transcoding on Vimeo, but it really does nothing for this cam. The OIS was especially effective to see in the video.  But other than that,  the quaility I'm seeing indicates that the video could have been shot by a much less expensive cam (not my setup, I have a 2K monitor and pro video card).   It would be nice if VM could post for download the source video direct from the cam and let readers decide if they way to download and view it on their own, in their NLE.   Also, while 5.1 sound may not be crucial to everyone, it is interesting that this cam supports 5.1 surround sound when using the SM-V1  surround sound mike.  It would be nice to explore this capability more and mention it in the copy.

Bern Rexer's picture

This camera works great for my use of corporate video recording and webcasting. However it doesn't meet it's potential. I'd hope that firmware, Magic Lantern or SDK would solve some issues. 

1) It is great to have a camera control unit via WiFi - but as soon as this camera begins recording you no longer have control of iris and other settings. Having control of the iris is one of the best uses of remote camera control. 

2) The user interface / menu takes a while to know - and to quickly get to the most used settings. The custom buttons do not offer all of the setting options.

3) My biggest complaint is not being able to quickly switch from auto exposure to manual exposure. I usually rough set exposure using the camera's automatic aperture - then with a single button or lens slider switch to manual exposure to increase or decrease F stop. This camera doesn't allow for a one step process to do so. It is great that, in manual setting, the custom button on bottom next to rotation knob allows you to toggle between aperture, shutter, and gain - then control those settings with the rotation knob - but there isn't a quick auto aperture to get out of the manual setting. If you set one of the other custom buttons to exposure - it doesn't work in manual setting.

Pros - gain does a fine job with low noise.

I hope these issues can be fixed with firmware updates.

 

This review applies to XA20 and HF G30 as they are essentially the same camera - same cmos and same menus.