Workstations Buyer's Guide: Your Best Guide to a New Computer

What do you need? What do you want? How do you decide? No matter the size, or importance of your editing needs, your budget will ultimately decide what you can have.

The best way to make a buyers guide is to break it down by budget. We are making assumptions about your needs and wants within the budget constraints. The best way to work within a tight budget is to plan around that budget. If you can't get everything you want now, you need to make a list and build your editing workstation slowly. Along the way you will be getting the latest versions, making your editing suite more robust. So why does Videomaker publish an editing workstation buyers guide? The gap between understanding how much of a computer system you need to properly edit video files, and successfully getting the editing program of your choice working at its best abilities is getting smaller every day.

For a video producer, there are a number of causes for confusion. When shopping at a big box retailer you will often get sales people that have little to no knowledge of your video editing needs. Are you editing large files? Shooting HD? Working with uncompressed footage? Will you be delving into 3D? The sales people can only rely on the system requirements for the editing software you will be using. This can lead to anger and frustration for the consumer. This happened recently to one of our readers who was lead astray by a salesman who knew nothing of video editing needs and tried to bluff his way into a sale. Our reader wanted to use Adobe Premiere Pro and was assured by the sales rep at an unnamed big box store that the computer she was interested in could do the job, no problem. Premiere Pro editing on a mini notebook?

Casual Shooter - Budget $2,500

This is the first price point and one where many of you will find yourself. At this level you need an editing machine that can fulfill all your editing needs. You also need this workstation to be scalable so you can make updates to it in the future. The Casual Shooters' needs will be editing videos from their camera as well as occasional high definition videos. They may also be interested in uploading videos to places like YouTube. As the Casual Shooter, you will need enough processing power to quickly handle encoding of these videos. While this price range seems like your choices would be limited they are not. An ADK 3800, for example, comes with a quad core Intel i7 CPU, three hard drives and a full-size case for future expansion as your budget allows. Your needs are at the beginning stage your software choices are Premiere Elements, the Sony Vegas editing software or Final Cut Express. These are all feature rich excellent editing software packages.

Expected Features:
  • CPU Speeds of at least 2.66 GHZ.
  • Minimum of 2 gigabytes of RAM
  • Choice of an Intel Core i5 or i7 processor.
Features to Look For:
  • Dual Processors.
  • Dual Video Cards for two monitor use

Serious Amateur - Budget $2,500 up to $5,000

At this level, you are working as a videographer at least on a part time basis. Your skills and equipment have grown, so should your editing equipment. The computer you choose to edit on will have more features and run a more robust program. Multiple higher end monitors can come in quite handy. You probably either have or are setting aside a dedicated room for editing. This means you can consider a full size or rack solution. You may not have big editing projects, but you need to have a machine that will not be slowed down by encoding or editing video. Processor speed as well as RAM are an imperative part of your system. Ample hard drive space is nice, but can be upgraded in the future when the budget calls for it. Multiple monitors is a nice luxury you may want to spring for.

The Alienware Aurora ALX comes with a quad core Intel i7, 6 gigabytes of RAM and dual video cards for under $3000. Leaving a lot of room in the budget for software and monitors.

Expected Features:
  • Multiple Fast Processors.
  • 3 gigabytes of RAM to start.
Features to Look For:
  • 6 gigabyte RAM range.
  • Multiple hard drives.
  • Multiple 1 gigabyte video cards to drive multiple monitors.

Rate This Article

Rating: 1 (Poor) - 5 (Excellent)

1 2 3 4 5
How would you rate the author of this article?
How Would you rate the overall value of this article?
How would you rate the graphics?
How would you rate this article's method (i.e interview, tutorial, narrative) for explaining this topic?
How would you rate the depth and length of the article?

Comments

You must be logged in to comment. Click here to login
X

Please Login or Sign Up to Participate

  • -or-
Marne Bass
likes, 2 dislikes
Its really obvious you guys don't like Apple - I know a fella that works there and he says its because you take money from Adobe and those other cheezy PC manufacturers. Consumer Reports you are not! You don't even talk about Final Cut - it's a dirty word to you guys! Every one of those computers you pitch in your article are really overpriced junk! Apples are what all the pros in Hollywood use. For the money you guys are talking about, you could get a quad core or 16 core Mac that will leave your junk at the gate - it's just they won't pay for you to review it! They don't need your help, they're selling like crazy. Those other guys will be out of business in a year or two when they self-destruct. Look, I got a used $500 iMac on Ebay and put 4G RAM (<$100) and a 2TB (WD Green refurb, $100) drive in it and it runs at the equivalent of 6GHz on a PC. It's a 2.16 GHz 20" and it comes with a second video out built in so I can use two monitors. I also use a D-Link DNS-323 network storage with 4 TB in it ($365 total). If I go to over to Safeway to get a sandwich FCP automatically renders everything so when I get back from the deli, all my stuff is ready. I had money left over so I got three other ones and gave them away. Everyone loves them, says they are so much easier to use than the junk they used to use. Who would you give a computer to if you could? I should write your articles for you and maybe people would be advised to get something practical.
Ian
Hi Marne, I would love to know how your Mac with its 2.16GHz processor is the equivalent to 6GHz on a PC. I'm pretty sure the guys at Intel would be interested to know that one too!! It may be true that these guys are ignoring Macs and that the review PC's are grossly overpriced but don't make stuff up it totally invalidates any point you are trying to make!!
john in covina
likes, 0 dislikes
I'd like to see an article on entry level home video editing. $2500 as a low end for home video editing seems like more than simply a hobby. Not all of us have that kind of disposable income, especially in this economy.
MDuLQQk1
Wow Marne, let everyone know how you really feel! PC's, Macs... who cares. People gotta start somewhere. I use a PC, I use Adobe Programs. I will, eventually, switch to a Mac and purchase FCP, but I don't need someone bad mouthing what I currently use, which is just fine by the way. Don't slam your favorite hardware/software down other people's throats. I will also upgrade from my currentl CS3 to CS5.5, I've heard nothing but good things with CS5.5
robreese
Yeah, I have to agree with Marne. I don' understand how this article could be written with not ONE mention of Macs. I know a lot of people who work with video, and the PC users are very much a minority - and they are always complaining about have to upgrade and maintain their systems. It's really strange that you guys are so one-sided.
sharirose
likes, 0 dislikes
AS John in covina said, $2500 is not in my price range. I've done alot of video editing over the past 8 years, but it's all personal...condensing footage and making videos enjoyable to watch of all our travels and documentaries for the family. I'd like to learn how to do it more efficently and quickly on a reliable platform. Thanks to Videomaker, I've come a long way.
Julie Babcock
likes, 0 dislikes
Hi Marne, Thanks for sharing your thoughts with us. From what I can tell, you are a very enthusiastic Apple user. Rightfully so; they have some great products. As a matter of fact, I own a Mac at home and edit on Final Cut Pro. I also own a PC and use Adobe software. In my opinion, both systems have their pros and cons. Neither is flat-out superior, and I wouldn't go as far as calling either system complete "junk." I don't know who this "fella" is that you speak of, but if he really did work here, he would know that the editorial staff reviews products that we think our readers would find interesting, regardless of what our sales department is doing. Your claim that we never mention any Apple products is unwarranted. A simple search on our site for "Apple" brings up eight pages of results. Not to mention, we awarded Final Cut Pro X the Videomaker Best of NAB 2011 award for Best Editing Software. To be honest, I'm not sure if Apple advertises with us or not; I've never checked. For me, and the rest of the editorial staff, advertisement revenue is a non-issue. We enjoy bringing our readers information on the newest products that are available to us to review. If they are not made available to us, we simply can't review them. Perhaps you should take your complaint to Apple.

Latest Videos

  • How to Block Shots How to Block Shots
    Before you start to roll camera, you and your team need to know what the actors will be doing and where they'll be positioned. This step is called blocking, and …
  • How to Organize a Shoot How to Organize a Shoot
    In this how-to training video we show you how and why to assemble a storyboard, organize your resources, and manage a production schedule. When film-making, tim …
  • How to Cast a Video Production How to Cast a Video Production
    Here we show you how to bring your characters to life by casting the best talent you can for your production. We show you where to look for actors, and walk you …

Connect with Videomaker

Facebook YouTube Twitter Newsletters Newsletters

Videomaker eNews

Videomaker eNews contains industry news and informative articles about video-related products, tips & techniques, special offers, events information and exclusive discounts. And now, sign up to receive Videomaker eNews and download Editing Dirty Little Tricks free! Learn the Band-Aid-type fix-it solutions the pros use.