You are here

Video Editing Cards

Video Editing Cards

Fast and efficient, if you want to get video onto your computer (and we assume you do) you'll need an interface card.

Yep, personal computers are a lot faster than ever before. So fast, in fact that it's perfectly possible for someone to dive in and do video editing on many manufacturer's basic turnkey computer systems without the need to add on any video-specific hardware. But does that mean that a turnkey is the best approach?

Long-time practitioners of desktop editing know that with a task as demanding as video editing, sometimes the smart approach is to relieve the computer's CPU and offload the capture tasks to some speedy dedicated hardware. Enter the Digital Capture card. The heart of many desktop video-editing systems.

Digital capture cards take an incoming video stream, whether via Analog input, IEEE1394 (FireWire) or even high end formats like SDI and they transfer it to your hard drive. Sometimes, this involves converting the data into the kind of digital files that your software can handle.

The market for these dedicated digitizers is well established. You'll find a wealth of choices from simple cards built to handle basic digitizing tasks to state of the art hardware capable of handling the huge data rates necessary to handle new high-definition video signals.

To help you decide which card might make sense for you, let's take a look at some of the most popular choices, what you can expect to get and how much you should expect to pay for the capabilities you'll get.

Ponies

Capture Cards under $100

  • Plextor ConvertX PX-AV100U $79
  • Pinnacle StudioDC10+ $100
  • IntroDVsoft 0775 $80
  • ADS PYRO $80
  • MovieDVSuite $90

In the economy space, the good news is that technological advances over the past few years have put new levels of capabilities into most manufacturers basic product lines.

In fact, at the low end, you might not even need to crack open your computer case. Products like the Plextor ConvertX PX-AV100U are a "card in a box" solution, which has all of the video capturing capability that a true beginner may need. Just plug the box into your computer's USB port (often USB 2.0 for full-frame, full-resolution), install the basic capture software and start digitizing your favorite tapes.

Of course you don't get any of the bells and whistles that arrive as you move up the video capture pedigree track. If your needs are simple, however, devices like this make it amazingly simple to get started. Video editing really is for the masses and not just for the "serious" amateur struggling with her first indie film.

For just a few more bucks, you can move into a lower cost analog card (Pinnacle Studio DC10+) or even one of the entry-level DV cards like the Pinnacle Studio DV or the basic PYRO card from ADS Corporation.

Remember that some products concentrate on analog conversion allowing you to feed any signal from any video source and digitize the video stream in preparation for using the clips in your editor. Other cards are FireWire compliant, meaning that they can directly accept a digital video signal via an IEEE-1394 cable. This key to making a good choice in a capture card is to understand what kind of video source you are trying to get onto your computer and then concentrate on the cards that match your computer's capabilities.

Trotters

Capture Cards from $100 - $400

  • Canopus Let's Edit RT $329
  • Dazzle DM4100 $ 240

In the $100 to $400 arena, you can start to expect some additional capabilities for your money. Cards in this class often go beyond simple digitizing and move up the quality scale. When you move into this area, it's also necessary to spend a little more time reading the specs to determine if the card you're considering matches the capabilities of the host machine.

For example, in the Canopus line of cards, the Let's Edit RT solution at $329 runs on a variety of Windows software systems including XP Pro and provides not only FireWire and analog inputs but also has 24-bit color processing at a resolution of 1024/768. Many of the effects and transitions happen in realtime (RT) and so you often do not have to wait to for renders. That's a pretty cool feature that software-only editing solutions can not always promise.

Workhorses

Capture cards from $400 - $2,000

  • Pinnacle Liquid Edition Pro $1,000
  • Matrox RT.X100 $1,099
  • Canopus DVStorm $1,699

Stepping up to the workhorse level buys you lots of additional video processing capability. One area to look for is the color correction capabilities available in this level of card. Onboard color correction at the capture level can help you fix that indoor footage shot at an outdoor white balance settings and, ultimately, save you time.

Perhaps the primary feature of these cards is the integrated package you purchase, which likely won't just consist of basic hardware. Instead, you'll find most cards in this class bundled with a nice suite of add-on applications. Sometimes, you'll find that the complete hardware/software package doesn't cost much more that just the software by itself.

Pinnacle Liquid Edition, for example, comes with not just the capture hardware, but also with Commotion Pro for motion graphics effects, TitleDecoPro for upgraded titling and Impression Pro for burning DVDs.

Another product with a long-standing reputation is the Matrox product line. The RTX.100 has both NTSC & PAL capabilities and at just $1,099 has both Analog and DV inputs and outputs with some realtime 3D effects capabilities and a full suite of Adobe editing software. The board also has a great breakout box, making it easy to connect (and disconnect) your camcorder to your computer without crawling around under your desk and wrestling with cables in the dark.

The hallmark of the capture cards in this class is dedicated hardware rendering, purpose built to streamline the entire video editing process. You get lightning fast video processing, along with advanced input/output functions such as the ability to digitize not just analog and more resolutions of digital video streams, but high-resolution audio as well. Often, as with the Canopus DVStorm, you can get onboard MPEG-2 rendering, which means that you can either capture in DVD-ready MPEG format or convert your edited source video to MPEG in real time.

Thoroughbreds

Capture Cards $2,000 and up

  • Canopus DVREXRTPRO $4,499
  • DPS Velocity DPSV3D-4500 $4,995

Okay, clearly if you're considering a purchase of capture cards costing more than $2,000, you're either a wealthy hobbyist or you're planning on using your video editing system for some real money-making work. And when your career is video, time is money.

Moving into the top tier of thoroughbreds means that you can expect the fastest possible video throughput. State of the art capabilities should also be present for everything from color correction to handling lots and lots of tracks of video and audio all with real-time previews and live video output. Additional capabilities include quick hardware encodes to MPEG for DVD mastering.

At the top of the heap, you should also look for the raw horsepower to allow you to send virtually any stream of video through your system, from simple DV to uncompressed HD. Check the inputs and outputs on these cards and look for SDI and component inputs and outputs as well as uncompressed capture and processing. If you don't need this sort of interface (or don't know what we're talking about), you don't need one of these cards.

Whether your needs are modest capture card ride for pleasure or if you're looking for the video equivalent of a Triple Crown winner, one thing is certain: The race is on.

Bill Davis writes, shoots, edits, and does voiceover work for a variety of corporate and industrial clients.

Tags:  September 2004
Bill
Davis
Wed, 09/01/2004 - 12:00am

Comments

mcfredoc's picture

Great stuff you have here. I am saddled with the task of setting up and running a small church video studio. At the moment I use a dell desk top with firewire, and adobe premire to capture from a panasonic 9000 HDV camera and capture real time. And its doing just fine. 1. After 1 hour service I get about 12gig size of footage. How can I get less with good video quality. 2. If I get additional camera what hardware or software will I need to do real time editing, capturing using the two cameras
Daniel Bruns's picture

Hey Fred, Great question. I'll do my best to give you an answer here. First of all, you may want to consider using a different capture method or buying a different camera so that you can ingest the footage to your computer faster than real time. Doing so will not only save you time but will save you the errors that HDV tape will inevitably have (such as dropouts, broken heads, timecode errors, etc). Using a different capture method will also potentially lead to smaller file sizes since, depending on their speeds, different mediums can capture to different formats. The HDV format is actually a very compressed video codec already but is unfortunately at a lower resolution (1440x1080), but there are other codecs that have a higher compression but still have a high resolution output. AVCHD, which can be found in most camcorders today, is one such codec. Though it will take more processing power to edit on your machine, it writes files that are much smaller and still at a higher resolution (1920x1080) than HDV. As such, I would recommend getting either an AVCHD camcorder or a device that can record from the FireWire output on your camcorder in AVCHD like the FireStore FS-H200, Atomos Ninja, and other DTE devices. Lastly, if you want to do real time switching and capturing using two cameras, I would suggest installing a Black Magic DeckLink card into the PCI-e port of your computer. This card will allow you to capture two independent video and audio streams and has plenty of connections. Telestream's Wirecast software can also switch between different video sources but cannot record a program edit. For an even higher end option, you could use a Tricaster Studio box that will allow multiple inputs and live switching. However, it costs quite a bit more than the other options. Grass Valley also sells a K2 Summit Media Server that would do the trick but again, it costs quite a bit. The bottom line is that it's not easy to combine a live switcher that is also a recorder in one machine. Especially in a computer using software. You'll probably end up having to use the computer as a switcher and then record the output from your video card on a separate streaming recording device (like a DVD recorder/player). Hopefully that helps!